Monday, 25 August 2025

Court cases on Rule 10 A – Restoration of Commutation Pension: Case Studies on Pension Cases

Court cases on Rule 10 A – Restoration of Commutation Pension: Case Studies on Pension Cases

 Case 4:

4. Court cases on Rule 10 A

4.1 Rule 10A of the Central Civil Services (Commutation of Pension) Rules, 1981, is a central point of contention in many court cases concerning the restoration of commuted pension. This rule stipulates that the commuted portion of a pension shall be restored after 15 years from the date the reduction of pension due to commutation becomes operative.

4.2 Key court cases and the issues surrounding Rule 10A:

1. “Common Cause” Society and Others vs. Union of India (1986 Hon’ble Supreme Court Judgment):

a) This is a landmark judgment that significantly shaped the policy on commuted pension restoration.

b) Before this judgment, there was no provision for the restoration of commuted pension. Pensioners who commuted a portion of their pension had that portion reduced for their entire lives.

c) The Hon’ble Supreme Court, in this case, considered factors like interest rates, mortality rates, and the commutation table in existence in 1986. The Hon’ble Court directed the Union of India to restore the commuted portion of the pension after 15 years from the date of commutation. This was viewed as an act of goodwill and relief for pensioners.

d) The Hon’ble Court noted that while the commuted amount might be recovered within a shorter period (petitioners argued around 12 years), the 15-year period accounted for the “risk factor” (the possibility of the pensioner dying before the commuted amount is fully recovered).

2. Forum of Retired IPS Officer (FORIPSO) vs. Union of India and Another (2019 Hon’ble Delhi High Court Judgment, upheld by Hon’ble Supreme Court):

  1. The Forum of Retired IPS Officers challenged Rule 10A, arguing that the 15-year recovery period was arbitrary and lacked a mathematical basis. They contended that the commuted amount was often recovered in a shorter period (e.g., 10.46 years in some cases).
  2. They highlighted that life expectancy had increased significantly since 1986, and the commutation factor had been downgraded. They also pointed out that the Fifth Central Pay Commission had recommended reducing the restoration period to 12 years, a recommendation not accepted by the Central Government, though some states had adopted it.
  3. The Hon’ble Delhi High Court rejected the petitioner’s contentions and dismissed the writ petition.
  4. Key Observations by the Hon’ble Court:
    1. Commutation of pension is an option exercised by choice, not mandatory.
    2. Issues related to commutation are policy matters, examined and decided based on recommendations of Pay Commissions.
    3. Courts should generally not interfere in such policy matters unless there is “complete arbitrariness and discrimination that is ex-facie apparent” or a “grave error” that necessitates interference to do justice.
    4. The Hon’ble Court explicitly stated that interference in such matters could lead to “all kinds of problems and cascading effects.”
    5. The Hon’ble Supreme Court later dismissed the Special Leave Petition against this Delhi High Court judgment, effectively upholding the Hon’ble High Court’s view that the restoration period is a policy matter for the Government to decide.
    6. 3. Highlights of the recent Demands:
      • Central Administrative Tribunal (CAT) Cases: Many individual pensioners and associations had filed and continue to file cases in various Hon’ble CAT Benches challenging the 15-year rule, seeking a reduction to 12 years. Some CAT benches have, at times, granted interim reliefs but later on stayed by higher courts, reaffirming the 15-year rule based on settled law.
      • Demands by Pensioner Associations: Various Pensioner bodies and staff unions consistently advocate for the restoration period to be reduced to 12 years, citing increase in life expectancy and the faster recovery of the commuted amount. The NC-JCM (National Council of Joint Consultative Machinery) has suggested including this as a term of reference for the 8th Pay Commission.
      • Government’s Stance: The Government has maintained that the 15-year period is based on expert recommendations and takes into account various factors, including the risk factor.
      •  The last two Pay Commissions (6th and 7th) did not recommend a change to the 15-year restoration period. 

      4.3 Despite ongoing demands for a shorter restoration period, the legal position, as of now, remains at 15 


Read More ->>

India Post Parcel Regulations 2024 - Administrative Instructions

 India Post Parcel Regulations 2024 - Administrative Instructions

1. Booking of Parcels

  • Parcels can be booked at post office counters, authorized franchisee outlets, self-booking kiosks, or through Department of Posts' web portal/mobile application
  • All domestic parcels must be accompanied by Customer Declaration Form (CDF-1) - Annexure I
  • Prohibited items for air transmission must be booked as India Post Parcel and sent by surface
  • Prohibited items list must be prominently displayed at booking counters
  • Contractual customers must provide item-wise declaration with invoice/list at time of booking

2. Packaging of Parcels

  • Parcels must be packed to not affect health of officials or damage other items/equipment
  • Packaging must follow specifications in Annexure III
  • Insured parcels must be sealed with identical wax seals featuring unique private mark
  • Tamper-evident tapes available at post offices may be used
  • Franchisee services may provide packaging assistance
  • Detailed packaging standards provided for different parcel types and materials

3. Transmission

  • India Post Parcel transmitted via surface (road/rail/waterways)
  • Speed Post Parcel transmitted via air, unless surface is faster
  • Parcel bags containing prohibited air items will be offloaded and marked "OFFLOADED BY AIRLINE"
  • Offloaded bags will be routed via surface connection

4. Delivery of Parcels

  • Delivery through post offices/Nodal Delivery Centers/designated places
  • Standard Operating Procedure in Annexure II outlines delivery process
  • Intimation to addressee required for accountable items
  • Undelivered parcels retained for 7 days after first delivery attempt
  • Addressee may request retention for up to 7 days with written instructions
  • Smart Delivery Boxes/franchisee outlets may be used for delivery

5. Disposal of Contraband Items

  • Parcels containing contraband will be dealt with as per Regulations 33-40

6. Cancellation of Booking

  • Cancellation available until parcel not dispatched from booking office
  • Requires original receipt, article number, and reason for cancellation
  • Valid identification required (KYC documents)
  • Supervisor approval required for cancellation
  • No refunds for domestic parcels

7. Recall of Parcels

  • Sender may have parcel with drawn or address changed (except when delivery in progress)
  • Application must be made to booking office in-charge with ₹6.00 fee
  • Bulk customer recall process detailed in Annexure IV

8. Compensation

  • Speed Post Parcel delay: Speed Post postage paid
  • Speed Post Parcel loss/damage: Double postage paid or ₹1000, whichever less
  • India Post Parcel (Retail) loss/damage: ₹100
  • India Post Parcel (Contractual) loss/damage: ₹500 or actual value, whichever less

9. Insurance

  • Contractual customers: ₹4 up to ₹200 value + 1.5% of value exceeding ₹200
  • Retail customers: ₹10 up to ₹200 value + ₹6 for every additional ₹100

10. Logistics Post

  • Handles parcels without specific weight limit (first slab: 50kg)
  • Provides end-to-end supply chain management
  • Operational process detailed in Annexure V

11. Cash on Delivery (COD)

  • Available for both Speed Post Parcel and India Post Parcel
  • Retail limit: ₹10,000; Contractual limit: ₹50,000
  • COD articles don't require insurance regardless of amount
  • Specific procedures for COD retail items (Annexure VI)

12. Discount Structure - Contractual Customers

  • Discount based on monthly revenue (10-30% for Speed Post, 7-20% for India Post Parcel)
  • Additional 1-2% discount for advance deposit or payment at booking
  • RTS limits: 25% for COD articles, 8% for non-COD articles
  • Reduced discount for paper manifests without soft copy
  • National Account Facility available for multiple location customers

13. Discount Structure - Retail Customers

  • 5% discount for daily revenue ₹2,000-₹100,000
  • 10% discount for daily revenue above ₹100,000

14. Operational Guidelines for Contractual Customers

  • Minimum revenue requirements: Single location ₹10,000/month, Multiple locations ₹50,000/month, National Account ₹10 lakh/year
  • Application process (Annexure VII) and terms & conditions (Annexure VIII)
  • Credit facility requires bank guarantee (Annexure IX)
  • Billing procedures and payment timelines
  • Non-payment penalties and consequences

15. Implementation

  • Instructions effective from date of implementation of PO Regulation 2024
  • Approved by Director General Postal Services

Read More ->>

Sunday, 24 August 2025

Public Notice

 Public Notice 


Read More ->>

India Post: A legacy built on service excellence, strengthened by IT 2.0 - Advanced Postal Technology (APT)

 India Post: A legacy built on service excellence, strengthened by IT 2.0 - Advanced Postal Technology (APT)

 

 

Read More ->>

Postal Service to US first to take the hit

 


Read More ->>

Saturday, 23 August 2025

Disbursement of salary/wages/pension to CG Employees/ Pensioners in Maharashtra State on 26.08.2025 on Ganapati Festival: CGA, FinMin O.M

 Disbursement of salary/wages/pension to CG Employees/ Pensioners in Maharashtra State on 26.08.2025 on Ganapati Festival: CGA, FinMin O.M.


F. No. 03002(2)/1/2020/TA-IT/(e-3001)/248- 310
Ministry of Finance
Department of Expenditure
Controller General of Accounts
Mahalekha Niyantrak Bhawan, E Block, GPO Complex
INA, New Delhi-110023

Date: 22-08-2025.

OFFICE MEMORANDUM

Subject: Disbursement of salary/wages/pension to the Central Government Employees in the State of Maharashtra for the month of August, 2025 on account of Ganapati festival-reg.

In view of the ‘Ganapati’ festival, the Government has decided that the salary of all Central Government employees in the State of Maharashtra for the month of August 2025 may be drawn and disbursed by the Central Government offices (including Defence, Posts & Telecommunications) on 26th August 2025 (Tuesday).

2. The wages for August, 2025 of the industrial employees of Central Government serving in the State of Maharashtra may also be disbursed in advance on 26th August 2025

3. The pension for August, 2025 of all Central Government Pensioners in the State of Maharashtra may also be disbursed by Bank/PAOs on 26th August 2025.

4. The salary/wages/pension so disbursed is to be treated as advance payments and will be subject to adjustment after the full month’s salary/wages/pension of each employee/pensioner is determined. The adjustment, if any, will be made without exception from the salary/wages/ pension of the month of August 2025.

5. The concerned Ministries/Departments are requested to bring these instructions to the notice of their offices located in the State of Maharashtra for necessary action immediately.

6. Reserve Bank of India is requested to bring these instructions to the notice of all paying branches of all Banks located in the State of Maharashtra for necessary action immediately.

(Sanchita Shukla)
Joint Controller General of Accounts (ARPR)

To

  1. All Ministries/Departments of Government of India.
  2. All Pr.CCA/CCA/CA/Dy. CAs of all Ministries/Departments of Government of India.
  3. The C&AG of India, Bahadur Shah Zafar Marg, New Delhi
Read More ->>

Friday, 22 August 2025

Hon’ble MoC reply on AIGDSU CHQ Letter

 Hon’ble MoC reply on AIGDSU CHQ Letter



Read More ->>

Thursday, 21 August 2025

Additional Pension – Policy, Legal Challenges, and Interpretations: Case Studies on Pension Litigation

 Additional Pension – Policy, Legal Challenges, and Interpretations: Case Studies on Pension Litigation

Case 7:

7. Additional Pension

7.1 One of the major objectives of the Department is to ease the lives of the pensioner and in this regard, Additional Pension as provided under Rule 44 (6) of CCS Pension Rule 2021 (erstwhile Rule 49) is one where Pension of the old Pensioners increases after completion of eighty years of age. The additional pension to old pensioners/family pensioners was introduced on the recommendations of the 6thCentral Pay Commission in view of their needs, especially those relating to health, which increases with age.

7.2 Rule 44 (6) of the CCS (Pension) Rule 2021 provides that after completion of eighty years of age or above by a retired Government servant, in addition to a pension or a compassionate allowance admissible under this rule, additional pension or additional compassionate allowance shall be payable to the retired Government servant in the following manner, namely: 

(i) From 80 years to less than 85 years – 20% of basic pension/ compassionate allowance

(ii) From 85 years to less than 90 years – 30% of basic pension/ compassionate allowance

(iii) From 90 years to less than 95 years – 40% of basic pension/ compassionate allowance

(iv) From 95 years to less than 100 years – 50% of basic pension/ compassionate allowance

(v) 100 years or more – 100% of basic pension/ compassionate allowance

The additional pension or additional compassionate allowance shall be payable from the first day of the calendar month in which it falls due.

Illustration: A pensioner born on 20th August 1942 shall be eligible for additional pension at the rate of twenty percent of the basic pension with effect from 1st August, 2022. A pensioner born on 1st August 1942 shall also be eligible for additional pension at the rate of twenty percent of the basic pension with effect from 1st August, 2022.

7.3 Despite the welfare-oriented approach adopted by the Government, several petitions have been filed in various courts challenging the policy and demanding the grant of additional Pension at a reduced age i.e. on completion of 79 years of age/start of 80th year of age. The case of Umashankar Joshi vs. Union of India is one such instance. Sh. Umashankar Joshi (D.o.B 01.10.1939), retired from Ordnance factory Itarsi (MP), filed O.A. No. 200/00971/2021 before Ld. CAT Jabalpur for grant of additional 20% pension on entering the 80thyear of age i.e. 01.10.2018 instead of on completion of 80 years on 01.10.2019. The Hon’ble CAT, Jabalpur Bench vide order dated 04.01.2024 allowed the OA based on the other Judgement dated 15.3.2018 of Hon’ble Guwahati High Court in WP(C) No. 4224/2016 in Virendra Dutt Gyani vs. UOI case which relates to the retired judges of Hon’ble High Court/Supreme Court.


7.4 Misc. Petition before Hon’ble HC Jabalpur has been filed by D/o Defence Production against said Order dated 04.01.2024 of Hon’ble CAT Jabalpur. The Hon’ble HC has stayed the Ld. CAT’s order. Matter is sub-judice.

7.5 Another OA No. 1379 of 2024 has been filed before the Hon’ble CAT, Mumbai by Shri Satyendra Kumar Singh Vs. Geological Survey of India. This OA is also seeking similar relief as that of Virendra Dutt Gyani. Matter has been taken up with M/o Mines and they have been provided a brief in the matter with interpretation of concerned CCS (Pension) Rules 2021. The matter is pending.

7.6 The Judgement dated 15.3.2018 of Hon’ble Guwahati High Court in WP(C) No. 4224/2016 in V.D. Gyani (a retired High Court Judge) vs. UOI (Ministry of Law & Justice) case, was an interpretation of the High Court Judges (Salaries and Conditions of Service) Act, 1954. The service conditions of the High Court/Supreme Court Judges are regulated by an Act of Parliament. This judgement is at variance to the orders/rules issued by the Government of India regarding additional pension under CCS (Pension) Rules 1972/2021.

7.7 In similar cases for additional pension on entering the 80th year of age, some other judgements of Hon’ble Karnataka High Court are there which contradict the above judgements. In its Order dated 16.12.2015 in Writ Appeal No. 100481/2015 (Commissioner, Hubballi-Dharwad Municipal Corporation vs. SV Budanhalli), Hon’bleHigh Court of Karnataka set aside an earlier order dated 27.4.2015 by the Single Judge and observed that attaining the age of 80 years means completion of age of 80 years. In another judgement dated 30.10.2019 (which is later than the order dated 15.3.2018 of Hon’ble Guwahati High Court) in WA No. 2487/2012 (Principal AG, Karnataka vs RG Desai), Hon’ble High Court of Karnataka observed that additional pension shall be admissible only on attaining/completion of the age of 80 years.

7.8 The policy under Rule 44(6) of CCS (pension) Rules 2021 clearly provides that the additional pension/family pension @20% of basic pension/family pension shall be admissible on completion of the age of 80 years and not on entering 80th year of age. In the service rules applicable to the Government servants, the phrase “attaining the age of” means ‘completion of certain age’. For example, as per FR 56, a Government servant is to retire on attaining the age of 60 years and accordingly, Government servants retire after completion of the age of 60 years.


7.9 There is, therefore, no scope for any other interpretation of these instructions/rules.

Read More ->>

Pensioners seeking benefit of revision of pension on the basis of up gradation of posts/pay scales – Legal Conflict: Case Studies on Pension Litigation

 Pensioners seeking benefit of revision of pension on the basis of up gradation of posts/pay scales – Legal Conflict: Case Studies on Pension Litigation

 Case 6:

6. Pensioners seeking benefit of revision of pension on the basis of up gradation of posts/pay scales which happened subsequent to their retirement.

6.1 Brief: Pre-2006 retirees are seeking benefit of revision of pension on the basis of up gradation of posts/pay scales which happened subsequent to their retirement against the instructions dated 11.02.2009 of DoPPW which stipulates that the benefit of upgradation of posts subsequent to their retirement would not be admissible to the pre-2006 pensioners.

6.2 The Hon’ble HC Delhi vide judgment dated 03.08.2016 in case of Ram Phal Vs UOI allowed the benefit of upgradation of post subsequent to retirement for the purpose of fixation of Pension (now pending before the Hon’ble Supreme Court in SLP No. 29383/2018 wherein operation stayed on 29.10.2018) and relying on this, the Hon’ble HC Delhi pronounced the judgment dated 14.09.2017 in Rajendra case in Writ Petition (C) No. 8113 of 2016. At present, Special Leave Petition 16321/2018 filed by UOI (against the Final Impugned Judgment and Order dated 14.09.2017 passed by the Hon’ble High Court of Delhi in Writ Petition (C) No. 8113 of 2016) is pending before Hon’ble SC.

6.3 Further, Ld. CAT PB, Delhi, in its order dated 6.11.2017 in the matter of Amrendra Nath Mishra & Ors Vs UoI & Ors in O.A. No. 1586/2010 has observed that the pension of pre-2006 pensioners is to be revised w.e.f. 1.1.2006 in terms of this Department’s OM dated 28.1.2013 read with OM dated 30.7.2015 (which was issued in implementation of the Ld. CAT’s order dated 1.11.2011 in O.A. No. 655/2010). Since the upgraded pay scale of Rs. 80,000/- fixed is applicable to those officers who came to occupy the post of Members of CBDT and CBEC on selection, Shri Mishra cannot be given the benefit of this scale for fixation of pension. The Ld. CAT, accordingly, dismissed the OA filed by Shri Amrendra Nath Mishra and some other similarly placed retired officers of CBDT/CBEC.


Read More ->>