Saturday, 31 July 2021

Conduct & Disciplinary Rules - 36 : Article from Mr. K.V.Shridharan

 Conduct & Disciplinary Rules - 36 : Article from Mr. K.V.Shridharan

Case Law on Conduct rules

6. The government servants are entitled to form an association and even if the said association is not recognized by the govt., such an association also has the right to file writ petitions in respect of any common grievance of the members of the association. This can happen only by the persuasion of many, by a few officials who take a leading part. Can such persuasion be characterized as instigation or deceit? Certainly not. But, that is what exactly has been done by the Disciplinary Authority in this case. Having considered the facts and circumstances of this case, I am convinced and I am constrained to hold that the institution of the Disciplinary Proceedings and the imposition of penalty of dismissal against the petitioners was a vindictive action by the Disciplinary Authority against the petitioners, as according to it these two petitioners were instrumental in filing the writ petitions. It is amazing that the Disciplinary Authority failed to realize the impropriety of instituting Disciplinary Proceedings against the petitioners on a charge of the nature set out earlier and spending considerable public time over it and imposing the penalty of dismissal and that the appellate authority confirmed the orders.

A.P.S.K.Sangh (Railways) X UOI AIR 1981 SC 98, V.K.Parameswaran X UOI & others (1982) 1 SLJ 516 Karnataka H.C.

7. Senior officers must exhibit exemplary conduct: Higher the ladder the officer scales in the echelons of service, greater should be the transparency of integrity, honesty, character and dedication to duty... The rights - constitutional or statutory-carry with them corollary duty to maintain efficiency, integrity and dedication to public service.."

K.Kandaswamy X UOI (1995) 6 SCC 162. 67.

8. Meaning of 'unbecoming conduct': Rule 3 (1) (iii) of CCS (Conduct) Rules, 1964 says that every government servant shall at all times do nothing unbecoming of a government servant, does not suffer from any vagueness or indefiniteness and is not constitutionally invalid on that ground. There cannot be an exhaustive list of actions which would be unbecoming of a government servant. Instructions under Rule 3, No. 22 give sufficient guidance in the matter of judging as to what is unbecoming conduct. Each case will have to be decided on the attendant circumstances in the context of norms of conduct of usually accepted standards of morality, decency, decorum and propriety.

Inspecting Asst. Commr. of Income tax X SK Gupta 80 CWN 74, Mahendra Kr. X UOI and anr. (1984) 1 SLJ 34 (AP). 

9. Meaning of 'unbecoming conduct/misconduct': The rules are not exhaustive in relation to the code of conduct specified in these rules. There exists what is known as an 'unwritten code of conduct which must be observed by every government servant... It is the duty of the government servant to be loyal, diligent, faithful and obedient. The liability to respect and the recognition of a subordinate role on the part of an employee also flows from the nature of the contract. Thus, disobedience, insubordination and acts subversive of discipline are the recognized misconducts because these acts are contrary to the obligations imposed on an employee by the nature of contract itself and can freely be treated as implied. It is for the employer to consider reasonably what conduct should be treated as misconduct. No general rule in this behalf can be laid down.

Agnani X Badridas & others (1969) 1 LLJ 684 (SC).

10. Innocent action on the part of a person cannot be held as misconduct.

UOI XJ.Ahmed AIR 1979 SC 1022.

 No malafide intention and no revenue loss. Cannot be treated as lack of devotion.

SLJ 1992 (3) 28 S.C 

Read More ->>

Conduct & Disciplinary Rules - 35 : Article from Mr. K.V.Shridharan

 Conduct & Disciplinary Rules - 35 : Article from Mr. K.V.Shridharan

C.C.S. (C.C.A.) RULES, 1965 – PRELIMINARY INVESTIGATION

I.                DEPARTMENTAL INQUIRY

Departmental inquiry is held:

(a) in the manner laid down in Rules 14 & 15 of the CCS (CCA) Rules for imposing MAJOR penalties;

(b) in the manner laid down in Rule 16 of the CCS (CCA) Rules for imposing MINOR penalties; and

(c) in the manner laid down in Rule 18 of the CCS (CCA) Rules for COMMON proceedings where two or more Government servants are concerned.

What is DEPARTMENTAL INQUIRY

A departmental inquiry is not a Criminal Trial in a Court of Law for imposition of punishment. It is not even lis between two parties which is decided by a third person. It is only a proceeding instituted by the Government in its capacity as the employer against its employee for the satisfaction of the mind of the Government as to whether the employee concerned has committed misconduct deserving imposition of penalty therefor. The inquiry is relevant to the contract of service between the parties, viz., the employer and the employee.

[A.R.R. Deshpande v. Union of India, 1971 (2) SLR 776 (Delhi).]

In cases of both criminal prosecution and departmental proceedings, the views and advice of the U.P.S.C. and the C.B.I. are to be taken into consideration by the Disciplinary Authority.

Before commencement of departmental disciplinary proceedings or criminal prosecution, a Government servant may be placed under suspension in public interest under the provisions of Rule 10 of CCS (CCA) Rules which will be discussed hereinafter.

Case law on Conduct Rules

Dear Comrades

Here some of the judgments related to conduct rules are furnished. Please read everything carefully and note down all these. When you are preparing replies to the charge sheets and explanation, you can make use of it. That’s why all these items are sent to you in word file

I.  CASE LAW ON MISCONDUCT

1. Meaning of misconduct: Misconduct is a generic term and means 'to conduct amiss; to mismanage; wrong or improper conduct; bad behaviour, unlawful behaviour or conduct'. There is a distinction between misconduct and grave misconduct. Misconduct in order to earn the epithet of gravity has to be gross or flagrant. Consequently the degree of misconduct to justify dismissal has to be higher or more serious. In order to gauge gravity of misconduct what matters is not frequency. It cannot, therefore, be contended that a single act of misconduct, howsoever grave, can never result in dismissal. What really matters is the enormity of the misconduct.

Bhagwat Parshad XIGPAIR 1970 Punj. 81.

2. Misconduct committed in private life: It is not correct to contend that a govt. servant is not answerable to govt. for misconduct committed in his private life. Assuming the contention to be correct, the result will be that, however reprehensible or abominable a govt. servant's conduct in his private life be, the govt. will be powerless, to dispense with his services unless and until he commits a criminal offence or commits an act which is specifically apprehended. This would clothe govt. servant with immunity which would place the govt. in a position worse than that of an ordinary employer. Art. 311 of the constitution does not restrict the power of the state to dispense with the services of any govt. servant for conduct which it considers to be unworthy or unbecoming of an official of the state, nor does it fetter the discretion of the state as to what type of conduct it shall consider sufficiently blameworthy to merit dismissal or removal. The state has been invested with absolute discretion in this respect. It can demand a certain standard of conduct from government servants not only when performing their official duty but in their private lives as well.

Laxminarain X Dist. Magistrate AIR 1960 ALL 55.

3. The right to demonstrate to improve prospects in service is a right to visible manifestation of feelings or sentiments of an individual or groups and this communication by one's idea to others to whom it is intended (is not a misconduct).

Balakrishnan Nair X Kerala 1980 KLT 264.

4. A mere technical violation is not misconduct. This means, e.g: a withdrawal form was passed without verifying the signature, but amount was correctly made to the correct party. 1992 (2) SLJ CAT 40 Cuttack

5. Peaceful assembly without any speech or slogans in office premises is not misconduct.

D (1994) 27 ATC 265 Madras.

Read More ->>

Conduct & Disciplinary Rules - 34 : Article from Mr. K.V.Shridharan

 Conduct & Disciplinary Rules - 34 : Article from Mr. K.V.Shridharan

C.C.S. (C.C.A.) RULES, 1965 – PRELIMINARY INVESTIGATION

I.                Government of India's instructions

1.      Domestic inquiry permissible where allegations have not been examined by the Court

The point to be taken note of is that one identical set of facts and allegation may be sufficient to constitute a Criminal Offence as well as misconduct not amounting to Criminal Offence, but punishable under the CCS (CCA) Rules. If the facts of allegations had come to be examined by a court of competent jurisdiction and the court has given a finding that the allegations are not true, then it is not permissible to hold a departmental inquiry in respect of the charge based on the same facts of allegations. If, on the other hand, the court has merely expressed a doubt as to the correctness of the allegation, then there may be no objection to hold a departmental inquiry on the same allegations if better proof than what was produced before the court or was then available is forthcoming. Then again if the court has held that the allegations are proved but do not constitute the Criminal Offence with which the Government servant is charged, then also there would be no objection to hold a departmental disciplinary action so also it is permissible to hold a departmental inquiry on the basis of the said allegation if such proved allegations are considered good and sufficient ground for departmental inquiry after the acquittal, in respect of a charge which is not identical with or similar to the charge in the criminal case, and is not based on any allegations which have been negatived by the Criminal Court. Furthermore, if the allegation had not yet been examined by a Court of law but are considered good and sufficient grounds for departmental disciplinary action, there is no bar to taking such action.

[Govt. of India, M.H.A., O.M. No F. 43/57/64-AVD (iii), dated the 29th November, 1966.]

Read More ->>

Staff Side NCJCM Meets Secretary DoPT Today (30.7.2021) to discuss 8 Agenda Items.

 Staff Side NCJCM Meets Secretary DoPT Today (30.7.2021) to discuss 8 Agenda Items. 

In the 48th Meeting of National Council (JCM) , it was decided that 8 Agenda Items i.e Agenda Item No.22 to Agenda Item No.29 will be discussed by Secretary (P) with Staff Side in a separate meeting. Accordingly , a meeting has been scheduled under the Chairmanship of Secretary (P) on 30th July 2021 from 11.00 AM in North Block New Delhi to discuss below items.

Coverage of JCM Scheme : All the Posts covered under PB-I and PB-2 may be deemed to be Group C posts for the purpose of JCM Scheme

  1. Litigation in service matters like Revision of Night Duty Allowance, MACP in Promotion Hierarchy , Placement of HS Grade I to be ignored for MACP to be resolved.
  2. Eradication of injustice to casual, Contract and Out sourced workers: providing them the right to form a Union in terms of Article 19 1(C) of the Constitution of India and Regularisation of Casual, contingent and outsourced workers
  3. Fill up all vacant Posts in all grades
  4. Grant of 5 effective upgradation to all Group B and C employees in entire service life
  5. Undertake cadre review of all Groups- B&C cadres in every five years before the cadre review of Group A cadres.
  6. Grant risk Allowance to the Employee involved in permanent and perennial recognised Risk operations
  7. Grant Night duty Allowance in 7th CPC Scale without any basic pay limit
Read More ->>

Stress on protecting tiger population to save forest.

 Stress on protecting tiger population to save forest.

Read More ->>

Departmental Exams 2021 put on hold till further orders

 Departmental Exams 2021 put on hold till further orders

Read More ->>

Privatization of long distance Trains - Rajya Sabha (Q & A) - 30-07-2021

 Privatization of long distance Trains - Rajya Sabha (Q & A) - 30-07-2021

Privatization of long distance Trains - Rajya Sabha (Q & A) - 30-07-2021


Read More ->>

Now file Income Tax Return at your nearest post office

 Now file Income Tax Return at your nearest post office

 Now file Income Tax Return at your nearest post office

Income-Tax Department has made it easier for taxpayers to file their returns. Taxpayers can file their Income Tax Returns (ITRs) at Common Services Centres (CSC) of their nearest post offices. India Post already announced the development giving a big relief to many.

India Post announced the same from its official Twitter handle on July 14, it said, “now no need to travel far to file your income tax returns. You can easily access income tax return services at your nearest post office CSC counter”.   

Post Office’s CSC counters spread across the country offer a number of financial services such as postal, banking, and insurance services to the people through a single point. These Post Office CSC counters offer a number of government services and information. The government also provides several other electronic services to the people under the Digital India programme.

Taxpayers can use Post Office CSCs in addition to the new income tax website https://www.incometax.gov.in./. Most users are comfortable filing online but a few who may not be as tech-savvy can use Post Office CSC to file their ITRs.

The new income tax portal 'www.incometax.gov.in' was launched on June 7 amid reports of glitches. as it continued to face tech glitches, which prompted Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman to call a meeting on June 22 with officials of Infosys which has developed the new website.
Read More ->>

Dearness Allowance and Dearness Relief from July 2021 confirm to be 31% with 3% hike

Dearness Allowance and Dearness Relief from July 2021 confirm to be 31% with 3% hike

 Dearness Allowance and Dearness Relief from July 2021 confirm to be 31% with 3% hike after release of CPI-IW for the month of June 2021

The Labour Bureau has publishes the All India Consumer Price Index for Industrial Workers (AI CPI-IW) for the month of June 2021. The index increased by 1.1 points and stood at 121.7 (one hundred twenty one and point seven). On 1-month percentage change, it increased by 0.91 per cent with respect to previous month compared to an increase of 0.61 per cent recorded between corresponding months a year ago.

Dearness Allowance and Dearness Relief from July 2021 confirm to be 31% 

Recently Govt. has approved and issued the order for restoration of DA/DR from July, 2021 form the rate accrued w.e.f. Jan, 2021.  The actual rate payable from July, 2021 now confirmed after the issuance of Consumer Price Index for Industrial Worker for the month of June, 2021.  The increase of 1.1. point in CPI-IW is registered with this issuance and Dearness Allowance/Dearness Relief is confirm to be 31% from July 2021 with 3% hike in existing rate. . Following table is showing that DA/DR from July, 2021 calculated to be  31%. This hike may be approved by the Govt. in month of September-October, 2021. 

DA/DR from July 2021 @ 31%: Table by staffnews.in

Expected DA from July, 2021 – Table by staffnews.in

Month

Base Year 2001 = 100

Base Year 2001 = 100

Total of 12 Months

Twelve monthly Average

% increase over 115.76 for 6CPC DA

% increase over 261.42 for 7CPC DA

7CPC DA announced or computed

Aug,19

320

3710

309.17

167.08%

18.26%

 

Sep,19

322

3731

310.92

168.59%

18.93%

 

Oct,19

325

3754

312.83

170.24%

19.67%

 

Nov,19

328

3780

315.00

172.11%

20.50%

 

Dec,19

330

3809

317.42

174.20%

21.42%

21%

Jan,20

330

3832

319.33

175.86%

22.15%

 

Feb,20

328

3853

321.08

177.37%

22.82%

 

Mar,20

326

3870

322.50

178.59%

23.36%

 

Apr,20

329

3887

323.92

179.82%

23.91%

 

May,20

330

3903

325.25

180.97%

24.42%

 

Jun,20

332

3919

326.58

182.12%

24.93%

24%

Jul,20

336

3936

328.00

183.34%

25.47%

 

Aug,20

338

3954

329.50

184.64%

26.04%

 

Sep,20

118.1

340

3972

331.00

185.94%

26.62%

 

Oct,20

119.5

344

3991

332.58

187.30%

27.22%

 

Nov,20

119.9

345

4008

334.00

188.53%

27.76%

 

Dec,20

118.8

342

4020

335.00

189.39%

28.15%

28%

Jan,21

118.2

340

4030

335.83

190.11%

28.47%

 

Feb,21

119.0

343

4045

337.08

191.19%

28.94%

 

Mar,21

119.6

344

4063

338.58

192.49%

29.52%

 

Apr,21

120.1

346

4080

340.00

193.71%

30.06%

 

May,21

120.6

347

4097

341.42

194.93%

30.60%

 

Jun,21

121.7

350

4115

342.92

196.23%

31.17%

 31%


Read More ->>